The Manchester United goalkeeper situation is a hot topic in football, with fans and analysts keeping a close eye. Since the Premier League began, the club has had only three consistent goalkeepers: Peter Schmeichel, Edwin van der Sar, and David de Gea. In between, they’ve had other keepers who haven’t inspired confidence.
Currently, Senne Lammens seems to be the top choice. However, there are rumors that Andre Onana wants to return and compete for his position, alongside the development of Radek Vitek, adding further complexity to the selection process.
While competition can be beneficial, this situation is proving to be more confusing than helpful.
Examining the Goalkeeping Battle at Manchester United
Senne Lammens: The Current Number One
Senne Lammens joined Manchester United for about £18.1 million, a deal that now appears to be a solid investment. Initially signed as a backup for Onana, Lammens has stepped up after both Onana and Altay Bayindir’s poor performances and secured the top spot.
Lammens has brought stability and reliability to the team. His recent match against Everton demonstrated his skills, as he commanded the area well and dealt confidently with challenging situations.
He has successfully adapted to changes in the team’s formation, shifting from three centre-backs to two, while maintaining a professional attitude. Praise from Sir Edwin van der Sar has likely boosted his confidence.
With Onana’s return, questions will arise about whether Lammens has truly claimed the starting position or if he’s simply holding it for Onana.
Andre Onana: Ready to Compete Again
Onana’s strengths in ball distribution were overshadowed by his struggles in goalkeeping fundamentals. He made critical errors that cost Manchester United points, and poor performances, such as one against Grimsby Town, ended his time at Old Trafford.
Now on loan at Trabzonspor, he has kept four clean sheets in 20 games. Onana hopes to re-enter the Manchester United squad upon his return in May and compete for his former position. However, his previous record may limit his chances.
The future manager may face pressure from the board to reintegrate Onana, especially considering his reported wage of £100,000 per week, which could increase if the team qualifies for the Champions League. With a contract until 2028, moving him might prove difficult, although he’s still capable at 29 years old.
Radek Vitek: The Rising Star
Fans might recall Radek Vitek’s name from his appearances on the bench in 2023. The 22-year-old Czech goalkeeper has developed his skills while on loan, now showing promise with 18 appearances for Accrington Stanley and later gaining experience in the Austrian Bundesliga. He is currently proving his worth at Bristol City.
Standing at 6ft 6in, he has kept nine clean sheets in 29 matches this season, ranking third in the Championship. If he helps Bristol City reach the playoffs, he could return with more options for Manchester United’s goalkeeping lineup.
What Manchester United Needs
Regardless of the choice—Lammens, Onana, or Vitek—Manchester United needs consistency in their goalkeeping role.
The goalkeeper must be confident, able to lead experienced defenders, stop shots effectively, and handle high balls. They should also adapt to different match scenarios, show leadership, and withstand pressure from opponents and the media.
As it stands, Manchester United’s goalkeeper situation needs clear direction.
Lammens is holding the position based on his performance. A strong finish to the season could cement his role, while Onana’s past suggests he may not get another chance easily. Vitek presents an intriguing option and could push Lammens for the starting role next season.
Ultimately, United needs to commit to their choice and build a defense around that goalkeeper.